Connect with us


Is water in cans greener than water in bottles? No.



Bottled water corporations are doing this due to public considerations about single-use plastic.

There’s a new bottled water in the marketplace, Ever & Ever, that is available in an aluminum can. It’s not alone; in keeping with the New York Instances, PepsiCo is testing canned Aquafina water. It is evidently in response to environmental considerations:

Lately, public sentiment has turned in opposition to single-use plastic objects, which might find yourself accumulating in landfills or floating in oceans. Internationally, solely 9 p.c of all of the plastic ever made has been recycled; against this, 67 p.c of the aluminum purchased by customers yearly is reused.

Ever & Ever, of their advertising and marketing, extols the virtues of aluminum with some splendidly artistic copywriting:

Ever & Ever is a love letter to aluminum, the eternal steel that has been round for roughly perpetually and can be round for roughly one other perpetually, taking no matter form people require of it, silently, selflessly, with out ego or waste, in contrast to plastic, which is a freeloader that’s fully comfy mendacity round in an ocean or landfill doing nothing.

The pitch that everybody is making is that an aluminum can is healthier for the atmosphere than a PET bottle as a result of aluminum is very easy to recycle. The issue is that it ain’t essentially so. Ever & Ever says “aluminum is infinitely recyclable” and “cans are constructed from a mean of 70 p.c recycled materials.”

The issue is that different 30 p.c. Even when recycling captured 100 p.c of aluminum (it does not), there would not be sufficient recycled materials to fulfill demand, as a result of the market retains rising and other people maintain considering up new makes use of for it, like canned water. Which means we’d like plenty of new aluminum.

mining bauxite© Getty Photos/ mining bauxite, the supply of Alumina

Making main aluminum is in virtually each method an environmental catastrophe. First it’s important to mine the bauxite in Jamaica, Malaysia and China, destroying agricultural lands and forests within the course of. Mining of bauxite ore has elevated from 200,000 tonnes in 2013 to just about 20 million tonnes final yr, due to elevated demand, primarily from China.

red mud spill© STR/AFP/Getty Photos/ pink mud spill in Hungary

Then it’s important to prepare dinner the bauxite in caustic soda and precipitate out the alumina hydrate. What’s left behind is poisonous “pink mud” that not too long ago brought about a flood in Brazil when the dam holding it again failed, and earlier buried a city in Hungary.

Then you definately prepare dinner the alumina hydrate at 2000°C to drive off the water to get anhydrous alumina, or aluminum oxide, which is what you make aluminum from.

Aluminum has been referred to as “strong electrical energy” as a result of it takes a lot of it to separate the oxygen from the aluminum in alumina. That is why it typically will get shipped off to Canada or Iceland the place there’s low-cost, clear hydro energy. However even there, they make it by sticking carbon anodes into pots in order that after they jolt it with electrical energy, the carbon and oxygen mix to make, guess what, carbon dioxide.

So in the long run, that 30 p.c of recent aluminum that goes into the can is simply concerning the dirtiest materials you may make, far worse than PET from a carbon and air pollution viewpoint.

This is the reason now we have to cease utilizing aluminum for ephemeral issues like single-use cans. As Carl A. Zimrig concluded in his e book “Aluminum Upcycled,” now we have to scale back demand in order that we need not make virgin aluminum.

As designers create enticing items from aluminum, bauxite mines throughout the planet intensify their extraction of ore at lasting price to the individuals, vegetation, animals, air, land and water of the native areas. Upcycling, absent a cap on main materials extraction, doesn’t shut industrial loops a lot because it fuels environmental exploitation.

And each time you purchase an aluminum can, that’s what you might be doing, fueling environmental exploitation. A British assume tank, Inexperienced Alliance is quoted in Meals Service Footprint after placing some numbers to it: “if half of the UK’s plastic water bottles switched to cans, mining the aluminium might generate 162,010 tonnes of poisonous waste, sufficient to replenish the Royal Albert Corridor over six instances.”

Two different much less vital however nonetheless vital factors:

Recycling aluminum nonetheless has its personal footprint.

As I famous earlier, quoting Carl Zimrig:

Aluminum is comparatively simple to recycle and reuse, however it isn’t as clear and straightforward as individuals assume. There are alloys that must be eliminated utilizing chemical substances like chlorine; there are fumes and chemical releases which can be poisonous. “….though the contaminants launched by recycling pale in comparison with the ecological harm of mining and smelting main aluminum, the waste merchandise of scrap recycling have to be thought-about when contemplating the implications of returning the steel to manufacturing.”

It isn’t “infinitely recyclable.”

It’s not “infinitely recyclable” and can’t be become something; in keeping with the Wall Road Journal, it is not truly adequate many makes use of (or Mac computer systems).”Outdated cans are much less versatile than different scrap. The makers of airplane and automobile components desire to not use aluminum constructed from recycled cans.” So the refiners aren’t bothering to recycle it since they get much less cash for it, and there is not sufficient can sheet for the can makers, so guess what, these aluminum cans are sometimes constructed from imported can sheet. Trump put a tariff on imported aluminum from China, so guess the place it is coming from, as I wrote earlier:

So everybody who feels OK consuming their beer and come out of aluminum cans as a result of “hey, they’re recycled” ought to understand that they aren’t, there’s more cash in automobiles so no person is bothering, and they’re simply going to waste. In the meantime, the can sheet is coming from… Saudi Arabia?

Ultimately, you can not say that an aluminum can is greener than a plastic bottle. It’s true that it will not find yourself floating within the ocean, however that’s the solely good factor you may say about it. Because the Inexperienced Alliance concluded: “refilling reusable water bottles is the one sustainable different to single-use plastic.”

What concerning the liner?

Lastly, there’s the query of whether or not there’s a lining within the can, and whether or not it accommodates Bisphenol A, a doable endocrine disruptor. I requested Ever & Ever they usually responded promptly:

…sure, every can has a skinny coating to increase product shelf life and to make sure the product’s high quality and style. The coating we use transcend regulatory compliance by way of elimination of BPA; the coating we use is a non-BPA epoxy. The coating has been authorised by the Meals and Drug Administration within the U.S. and the European Meals Security Authority.

The Ever & Ever individuals additionally make the case you could re-use their screw-top bottle; they even advocate giving it an affectionate identify like Samantha or Jake. They get factors for that, and for his or her copywriting. I may even think about individuals shopping for Ever & Ever as a result of they’ll simply fake that they carry a reusable bottle; I all the time complain to my sustainable design college students after they carry disposables to class, however what would I do with this?

However in the long run, no person ought to assume that an aluminum can filled with water is definitely higher than a plastic bottle of water. I believe that it’s truly worse. The one really sustainable option to drink water is from a reusable bottle, a glass, or from a consuming fountain. We have now to make use of much less aluminum and attempt to get rid of single-use aluminum merchandise to “shut the economic loop.” That is the truth.

Is water in cans greener than water in bottles? No.

Bottled water corporations are doing this due to public considerations about single use plastic.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


One less thing to worry about in your carbon footprint: whether your food is local



There are many good causes to purchase native, however don’t fret concerning the affect of delivery.

For some years we’ve got been consuming largely an area and seasonal food regimen, frightened concerning the carbon footprint of transporting all that meals throughout or between continents. It will possibly get fairly monotonous; when partner Kelly Rossiter was writing for TreeHugger about this, it was a food regimen of potatoes and turnips and extra turnips. As I attempt to reside a 1.5 diploma life-style we’ve got been consuming this sort of food regimen once more as I depend my carbon, and have already mentioned the massive footprint of purple meat. Nevertheless, Hannah Ritchie of Our World In Knowledge, out of Oxford College, has printed knowledge that present we will fear concerning the seasonal, however loosen up concerning the meals miles. She writes:

‘Consuming native’ is a advice you hear usually – even from distinguished sources, together with the United Nations. Whereas it would make sense intuitively – in spite of everything, transport does result in emissions – it is likely one of the most misguided items of recommendation…. GHG emissions from transportation make up a really small quantity of the emissions from meals and what you eat is much extra vital than the place your meals traveled from.LunchMeals: Kelly Rossiter. Photograph: Lloyd Alter/CC BY 2.0

Actually. I actually simply had this for lunch, a yummy Autumn Root Vegetable Gratin with Herbs and Cheese, as a result of it is made out of good previous native non-refrigerated potatoes, turnip and parsnip, as a result of Kelly is supporting me within the 1.5-degree food regimen. Now, the web is usually a little bit wider. However we’ve got at all times stated that consuming seasonally was extra vital than consuming regionally (no hot-house tomatoes, please) and Ritchie confirms it:

There are additionally plenty of circumstances the place consuming regionally would possibly in actual fact improve emissions. In most nations, many meals can solely be grown and harvested at sure occasions of the yr. However shoppers need them year-round. This offers us three choices: import items from nations the place they’re in-season; use energy-intensive manufacturing strategies (akin to greenhouses) to supply them year-round; or use refrigeration and different preservation strategies to retailer them for a number of months. There are numerous examples of research which present that importing usually has a decrease footprint.

My late mother at all times thought that getting asparagus in winter was the best luxurious, and naturally I’d complain concerning the air freight. However Ritchie confirms that that is the one form of well-traveled meals that we actually ought to keep away from, noting that the asparagus had a delivery footprint 50 occasions as excessive as produce that comes by boat.

Dwelling in North America the place a lot of the meals travels by truck, I frightened that her knowledge wouldn’t be as related right here, however in actual fact, American researchers got here to the identical conclusion:

By analysing shopper expenditure knowledge, the researchers estimated that the common American family’s meals emissions had been round eight tonnes of CO2eq per yr. Meals transport accounted for under 5% of this (0.four tCO2eq). Which means if we had been to take the case the place we assume a family sources all of their meals regionally, the utmost discount of their footprint can be 5%.

And their food regimen can be much more boring. I additionally questioned whether or not this included the entire chilly chain, the refrigerated warehouses and vehicles that transfer all of it throughout the continent, and even the packaging it is available in; it is all teensy, in comparison with the affect of land use and farm emissions.

From an emissions viewpoint, the only greatest factor you are able to do is surrender purple meat, regardless of how it’s raised, then lamb, after which cheese, in case you are counting emissions per kilogram of meals. However as my cheesemonger daughter retains reminding me, you possibly can’t examine a kilo of cheese to a kilo of apples; the caloric and carbon densities are completely totally different.

And it seems, she is true; Our World in Knowledge has a desk for that, too, measuring emissions per 1000 kilocalories, the place the order modifications considerably. Now shrimp is off the menu (it was anyway due to the way in which it’s harvested) and cheese is down there with the chickens, weirdly decrease than tomatoes.

I nonetheless imagine there are many good causes to go native; it helps the native farmers and the regional economic system. California strawberries are a drain on water assets and style like wooden, so we eat them seasonally. Our family rule is that if it grows right here (in Ontario, Canada) then we wait till we will eat the native model, however I nonetheless get to have a grapefruit for breakfast and a few guacamole at lunch.

American Meat Institute© Not in case you are on a low carbon food regimen/ American Meat Institute

Clearly the greenest food regimen of all is to go vegan, maintain the tomatoes. But when your dietary selections are based mostly in your carbon footprint, dropping the purple meat is the only most vital factor you are able to do, it doesn’t matter what the American Meat Institute tells you.

And it is good to know that I can take pleasure in my grapefruit and never fret about its journey footprint. It is one much less factor to fret about.

One much less factor to fret about in your carbon footprint: whether or not your meals is native

There are many good causes to purchase native, however don’t fret concerning the affect of delivery.

Continue Reading


Photo: View of the landscape from behind a waterfall



Our photograph of the day turns the everyday waterfall shot on its head.

We have come so accustomed to admiring waterfalls front-on – however what occurs while you view them from behind? Photographer david selvage reveals the reply on this great photograph taken from behind the Sgwd yr Eira falls in Brecon Beacons Nationwide Park, Wales. When you get your bearings on this photograph, you may see that the world considered by way of a curtain of speeding water is a beautiful one. (It should have sounded fairly superb too.)

Would you wish to see your nature photograph featured because the TreeHugger photograph of the day? Be a part of TreeHugger’s Reader Picture Pool on Flickr and add your footage to the group. Alternatively, ship it to with “photograph of the day” within the topic line.

Continue Reading


From frivolous to finely-tuned: How my clothes habit has evolved



I’m pickier, stingier… and far happier.

I just lately took ThredUp’s Style Footprint Quiz to calculate what number of kilos of carbon my vogue habits generate every year. It was a foolish little quiz, asking me to estimate the variety of tops and bottoms and clothes I purchase every year, what number of a great deal of laundry I do monthly, and whether or not I store in-store or on-line, however I nonetheless felt a surge of pleasure at seeing the end result: “You are a inexperienced queen! Your vogue habits contribute to 285 lbs of carbon emissions yearly. Your footprint is 82 p.c decrease than the typical client.” (It is nonetheless equal to almost two flights between San Francisco and Los Angeles, however hey, a lady’s gotta put on one thing.)

I did not at all times have these eco-friendly vogue habits. I used to buy weekly, filling my closet with cute fast-fashion items that seemed nice for just a few nights earlier than stretching, fading, pilling, and getting deserted. I would do occasional wardrobe purges that resulted in most issues getting tossed within the trash as a result of they seemed too shabby to donate. Maybe it is a mixture of growing old and maturity and all the training I’ve finished over the previous eight years as an environmental author, however there was a elementary shift in the best way I view garments procuring.

Most noticeably, I hardly ever buy new garments (and I am not shopping for something new this 12 months). There’s such nice used stuff obtainable that it makes little sense to spend extra cash on new. It may be enjoyable to chase down nice finds and peruse the racks of a great thrift retailer. Plus, I do know an excessive amount of about vogue manufacturing and don’t wish to contribute to but extra waste and air pollution. Extending the life span of another person’s castoffs is ok with me, even when it does take endurance.

I get pickier about how I spend my cash. (I have been studying a variety of monetary independence bloggers.) It appears insane to drop $250 on a number of tops and bottoms that may fall from favor inside just a few months, however I do not hesitate to spend that on a pair of high-quality winter boots or an insulated parka that I am going to put on each single day for 5 months of the 12 months for a decade.

I take note of issues I by no means used to care about – the kind and thickness of material, the place of birth, the maker, the seams. I do cautious examinations for holes and stains. I do sitting/squatting exams within the change room and apply taking an merchandise off. I think about how it might really feel layered with different objects or worn below a cumbersome coat or paired with sneakers I personal.

I’ve a brand new obsession with consolation. Whereas I used to purchase fashionable garments and endure them for ‘the look’, I refuse to try this anymore. (Perhaps I am getting outdated?) Except one thing feels completely improbable, I am not paying for it. Being attentive to consolation has helped me to develop a greater sense of private type and settle for that I’ve robust preferences, i.e. I want denims and dressy tops over clothes, I hate all excessive heels, I overheat rapidly and may at all times put on brief sleeves to events, and many others. (The weekly wardrobe planner, ‘A Yr of Nice Fashion’, helped me with this.)

My wardrobe is lastly reflecting my way of life. I used to fill it with a spread of clothes kinds, from informal to skilled to fancy, however the garments did not align with my precise life, most of which is spent sitting in entrance of a pc at residence, hanging out with youngsters, or going to the health club. I haven’t got knowledgeable workplace job, nor do I’ve cocktail events or company capabilities to attend. What I do put on most days are leggings, a comfy sweater, and thick socks. So that’s the place my focus must be, on buying items that I’ll put on in my actual life.

After I do purchase new garments, I plan it upfront and enter shops just for particular objects – and I nearly by no means pay full value for something. I head straight for the clearance racks behind the shop, which used to make me really feel embarrassed, however now I do not care in any respect. I watch for gross sales to occur, then swoop in to purchase. I do all of it in-store and by no means on-line, except I’ve tried on a selected merchandise earlier than and realize it suits properly.

Lastly, I do common and diligent purges twice a 12 months. I’ve very restricted closet and dresser area, so each spring I pack away my winter garments and convey out the summer season ones, then do the other within the fall. It is my likelihood to take away something that did not stay as much as my expectations or get worn usually sufficient, and donate again to the thrift retailer. It is simple to let go of items I’ve paid so little for and it helps to cement in my thoughts what I do and do not like carrying.

Yearly, I really feel like I get higher at dressing myself, at realizing my physique, at discovering kinds and offers that delight me, and removing the less-than-perfect objects from my closet. As a result of it is an ongoing problem, it by no means loses its pleasure.

I’m pickier, stingier… and far happier.

Continue Reading


LUXORR MEDIA GROUP LUXORR MEDIA, the news and media division of LUXORR INC, is an international multimedia and information news provider reaching all seven continents and available in 10 languages. LUXORR MEDIA provides a trusted focus on a new generation of news and information that matters with a world citizen perspective. LUXORR Global Network operates and via LUXORR MEDIA TV.

Translate »