Connect with us


What happened with West Virginia’s blockchain voting experiment?



Illustration of a blockchain over a map of West Virginia.

Picture illustration by Slate. Pictures by Getty Pictures Plus.

What a Mars Skilled Thinks Early Settlements on the Purple Planet Will Look Like

Who’s Utilizing License Plate Cameras to Observe Automobiles? Cops, Landlords, and Your Neighbors.

Fb’s Face-ID Database May Be the Greatest within the World. Sure, It Ought to Fear Us.

Appeals Courtroom Confirms That Trump Can’t Block Critics on Twitter

Final yr, West Virginia did one thing no different U.S. state had achieved in a federal election earlier than: It allowed abroad voters the choice to forged absentee ballots for the midterm election through a blockchain-enabled cellular app. In response to Voatz, the corporate West Virginia labored with, 144 people from 31 nations efficiently submitted ballots through the app for the November election. Earlier than that, there was a smaller pilot of the system in two West Virginia counties that Might.

West Virginia billed the experiment as successful and says it plans to make use of the know-how once more in 2020. Voatz has already made offers with different native governments within the U.S., most lately for Denver’s Might municipal election.

However how safe and correct was the 2018 vote? It’s inconceivable to inform as a result of the state and the corporate aren’t sharing the fundamental data specialists say is important to correctly consider whether or not the blockchain voting pilot was really a powerful success. With 2020 looming, that’s troubling, given what we now know concerning the extent of Russian incursions into our election techniques in 2016.

State officers in West Virginia mentioned the purpose of rolling out the cellular voting choice was to make voting simpler for troops residing overseas. However West Virginians abroad didn’t should be within the army to reap the benefits of the method. All residents needed to do was register, obtain the app, undergo just a few verification steps corresponding to importing a photograph ID and taking a video selfie, and make and submit their poll alternatives on the display screen. And all of it was mentioned to be safe. With the blockchain know-how it used, the agency insisted, the votes can be near-impossible to hack. (Blockchain is a digital public ledger that information data. It may be shared and utilized by a big, decentralized community, so it’s theoretically extra proof against tampering.)

However quite a few election know-how specialists sounded the alarm over what they mentioned was the big potential for glitches and safety dangers on folks’s cellular gadgets, the networks that hosted them, and the servers that held their data. Amid the phrases and phrases they used to explain West Virginia’s experiment: “horrible,” “horrific,” “utterly nuts,” “high-flying blockchain guarantees,” “the Theranos of voting,” and “no.” Some pointed to the shortage of transparency across the app, others to the inherent weaknesses of conducting an election over the web in any respect.

Our closest take a look at the small print of the voting experiments got here in an eight-page white paper revealed in February, but it surely was quick on particulars. Within the report, Voatz mentioned that it had retained 4 unbiased safety specialists to audit its system. Although the white paper included “enjoyable details for election geeks,” it failed to call any of those auditors. Additionally unlisted: the scope of the exams performed, what precisely the auditors had entry to, how lengthy they needed to carry out the exams, what vulnerabilities had been found, the severity of these vulnerabilities, and whether or not or not they had been fastened.

When requested about why a redacted audit or report from the auditors wasn’t launched, Voatz co-founder and CEO Nimit Sawhney, who co-authored the white paper, gave a number of causes. First, he pointed to a nondisclosure settlement with the auditors. Then, he said that there was no strategy to share any extra details about the audit with out revealing proprietary details about the system. However one would count on a redacted report and even an summary of the report for transparency’s sake, given the stakes of introducing a brand new system to our already rickety voting course of. Relying on the secrecy of its system structure is such a poor safety mechanism that researchers have even coined a time period for it: safety by obscurity.

To its credit score, Tusk Philanthropies, the group that funded most of Voatz’s cellular voting pilots, contracted ShiftState Safety to conduct its personal, separate audit and to overview the opposite audits and penetration exams (the place auditors search for safety vulnerabilities that attackers may exploit). ShiftState Chief Safety Officer Andre McGregor instructed me that the agency deployed “a few consultants,” together with himself, over a month to conduct a full safety overview, interview Voatz workers, and see whether or not penetration exams performed by one other agency had been in keeping with the outcomes one would count on from a pen take a look at of that sort of software program stack. McGregor mentioned Voatz “did very nicely” within the audit. However he declined to reply a number of questions due to a nondisclosure settlement he had signed with Voatz. After Voatz Senior Vice President Larry Moore instructed me that the corporate would launch McGregor from his NDA, McGregor said that any interview questions would must be despatched through e mail, however he didn’t reply to these.

Voatz’s lack of transparency makes it onerous to verify if votes had been tabulated precisely. A very powerful a part of conducting a post-vote tabulation audit—a strategy to obtain confidence that reported election outcomes are appropriate—requires taking a random pattern of ballots that mirror the true intent of the voter. That is the place having a paper path from voting can come in useful. With machines that generate paper ballots or conventional paper-based voting, you’ll be able to maintain the piece of paper and confirm it earlier than placing it right into a scanning tabulator.

Voatz’s web site states that “a paper poll is generated on election night time” and is tallied “utilizing the usual counting course of at every collaborating county.” What meaning is the voter’s vote is shipped to the county clerk workers as a PDF, and the county clerk workers prints it out and places it into the scanning tabulator. These paper ballots generated from the PDF would possibly nonetheless be helpful to audit the tabulator itself, however not the voting course of, because the voter by no means had an opportunity to overview the paper instantly. This requires the voter to belief that the federal government will do all this appropriately behind the scenes.

“There isn’t something like that to verify if you’re utilizing web voting or cell phone voting, so there’s no method to return and be sure that the tabulation was appropriate and that it matches one thing the voter intends,” mentioned Audrey Malagon, mathematical adviser for Verified Voting, a nonpartisan nonprofit that advocates for regulation and laws selling accuracy, transparency, and verifiability of elections.

Voatz’s web site additionally says {that a} postelection audit can examine “the paper ballots with the anonymized voter-verified digital receipts generated on the time of vote submission.” However a carbon copy of a cellular or on-line vote is just not a paper poll, and evaluating that receipt with the outcomes is just not a tabulation audit. “With the intention to have an genuine tabulation audit, you might have to have the ability to audit one thing that the voter has been capable of confirm, and so any time you’re introducing these additional steps and further processes, you might have the additional potential for error,” Malagon mentioned.

Sawhney says that every voter receives a verifiable receipt of their vote and has the flexibility to verify whether or not it represents their intent, and an nameless carbon copy of the e-mail is shipped to the jurisdiction. The tabulation audits have been performed based mostly on the copies despatched to the jurisdiction. However what if the signature scheme is damaged or an e mail wasn’t correctly despatched to each recipients? “The one factor a voter can really confirm is one thing that the voter sees. If the voter is in a single place a voter-verifiable receipt and another person is in one other place a printed poll that supposedly matches that receipt, how do we all know that it really does?” requested Mark Lindeman, Verified Voting’s senior science and know-how coverage officer.

Voatz’s use of blockchain doesn’t remedy this downside. Advocates of blockchain voting level out that the blockchain is proof against tampering, which they are saying can shield the method. However anybody who has voted on this method would possibly wish to verify their vote within the blockchain to ensure it’s really there and says what they supposed. Though Voatz is hoping to vary this sooner or later, its customers at the moment don’t have any method of doing so. And producing paper ballots that the voters are unable to see or confirm is just not sufficient.

Even when Voatz does handle to construct a viewer permitting voters to confirm their votes throughout the blockchain, it nonetheless doesn’t remedy the issue of tabulation audits, the place utilizing random samples is a part of the purpose. And it’s not doable to establish whether or not carbon copies of voting receipts mirror voters’ intent the way in which paper ballots can.

Discovering a technical resolution that can enable voting techniques to indicate that what’s being recorded, counted, and saved within the blockchain displays the voter’s intent with out compromising the voter’s secrecy isn’t straightforward. That’s why many specialists assume that blockchain isn’t an applicable software for voting, at the least not but.

Voatz has promised extra white papers, and that future audits might be performed by third-party companies and might be within the public area earlier than 2020. If that occurs, it could be a step in the proper path. An audit of the vote in Denver was performed by the Nationwide Cybersecurity Heart, a nonprofit group established in a invoice signed by former Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper, who’s the founding director and has a nonvoting seat on the board. The tabulation audit was, once more, performed based mostly on receipts. The audit itself was, at the least, extra clear, with an audit course of demo and video posted publicly, together with a Fb Stay video by the Denver Elections Division.

Extra audits by the U.S. Division of Homeland Safety are deliberate too, although it’s unlikely that the outcomes might be shared publicly in a significant method. Donald Kersey, normal counsel and former elections director/deputy authorized counsel for the West Virginia Secretary of State’s Workplace, mentioned that penetration testing might be achieved by the Division of Homeland Safety in the summertime and fall, and that exams will embody on-site inner intrusion makes an attempt within the fall. This can generate an audit report, however not one which’s public, although Kersey plans to summarize it for voters. When requested how voters can decide whether or not he’s cherry-picking from the report, Kersey mentioned, “If there’s one thing insecure, we wish to find out about it, and if it will possibly’t be mitigated, we’re not going to make use of it.”

“No person’s focused on placing out one thing that isn’t protected and lower than a sure normal,” mentioned Sawhney. “We consider it’s fairly strong and does what it claims to do.”

However “fairly strong” is just not ok in the case of voting securely. And with out seeing a correct tabulation audit or different particulars about the way it works, we merely can’t consider it.

Future Tense
is a partnership of
New America, and
Arizona State College
that examines rising applied sciences, public coverage, and society.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Christian Decker – The World’s First Bitcoin PhD by The Blockchain and Us: Conversations about the brave new world of blockchains, cryptoassets, and the • A podcast on Anchor



Anish Mohammed speaks about his profession as a cryptographer, the brilliance of Bitcoin, tokenizing transport, the mechanics of token economics, advantages of tokeninzation in creating and developed international locations, token engineering, how the growing specialization within the token engineering area can change into a bottleneck, how he moved from medication into cryptography, how he evaluates if he desires to work with a crew on a blockchain challenge, private worth techniques, how exhausting it’s to boost capital for his personal startup Ontici, the doom of ICOs, zero-knowledge proofs, and his basic curiousity about all issues know-how.
Anish has been in safety and cryptography for the reason that 12 months 2000 as a researcher and advisor. He has labored for a number of monetary establishments and is likely one of the founding members of the UK Digital Forex Affiliation. He’s on a number of advisory boards together with Adjoint, Arteia, Hyperloop Transport Applied sciences, Privateness Shell, Collider-X, Look applied sciences, Ripple Labs, and Chain of Issues. His most important work immediately concentrates on safety, scalability, and consensus of blockchains and sensible contracts for AI security, cryptoeconomics and token engineering. Anish a daily speaker and the co-founder of Ethicsnet, the co-founder & CTO of Ontici, Chief Science Officer at Blockchainsmokers,  and the pinnacle of analysis on the Info Sciences Institute at SRH Berlin.
Anish Mohammed:,
UK Digital Forex Initiative:
Many due to our sponsor!
This episode has help from Shift Cryptosecurity, the maker of BitBox, a minimalist {hardware} pockets for cryptocurrencies. BitBox is rock-solid, compact, moveable, straightforward to make use of, and designed and manufactured in Switzerland. To be taught extra and get your pockets immediately, go to

Continue Reading


The Future Of Asset Management



Presently, the asset administration trade is opaque, inefficient, and risk-prone

Blockchain expertise allows the digital illustration of property utilizing good contracts

Tokenization, in itself, has the potential to remodel asset administration

Asset administration is a pivotal course of for any group. But, in its current state, the asset administration trade itself is rife with points equivalent to forgery, a number of variations of the identical doc, and lack of transparency. By enabling asset tokenization, Blockchain can play a serious function within the transformation of the bodily asset administration course of.

This may be finished by automating duties with the assistance of good contracts, eliminating info mismatches utilizing the distributed ledger as a single supply of fact, and avoiding tampering of knowledge with cryptographic encryption and time stamp.

In what follows, we discover the methods through which environment friendly, seamless, and safe asset tokenization on Blockchain can usher a brand new period in asset administration.

The Current State of Asset Administration

Earlier than taking a look at how asset tokenization may assist, it’s crucial to know the involved trade in its present state.

In short, asset administration is your entire technique of manufacturing, procurement, storage, and administration of asset-related paperwork earlier than, throughout, and after the method of possession switch. It’s utilized for the commerce of shares, bonds, real-estate, equities, and different comparable property.

The multi-stakeholder asset administration ecosystem entails a lot of intermediaries, together with brokers, custodians, auditors, and traders. Because of this, the general value of the method rises. Additionally, it heightens the danger of errors and fraud.

Consequently, the trade, at current, is stricken by points equivalent to,

Fragmented information storage – Each social gathering has its personal model of the information, resulting in inefficiency, opacity, and low reliability.Lack of accountability – When it happens, this can be very tough to pinpoint the supply of error, given the complexity of the processes.Advanced onboarding – The onboarding course of is lengthy, gradual, and susceptible. The fraudster can use solid paperwork and faux IDs to get onboard.

Asset Tokenization – In direction of The Future

Tokenization is the method of representing real-world property within the type of tokens issued on the Blockchain. It encompasses a spread of asset lessons, together with fairness, shares, shares, bonds, actual property, treasured metals, art work, or different types of mental property.

Typically, it broadens the scope for funding, lowers processing time, and makes processes extra liable. For asset administration, specifically, tokenization provides the next advantages.

Seamlessness – Utilizing good contracts, it’s doable to automate your entire technique of doc manufacturing, storing and managing them. On a distributed ledger (Blockchain), each social gathering has a replica of the identical model of a doc. This helps in avoiding any mismatches of knowledge.Safety – Blockchain-enabled decentralization eliminates the dangers concerned within the conventional single-point-access mannequin of the trade. Furthermore, property on Blockchain are cryptographically encrypted, making them tamper-proof.Enhanced Management – House owners of tokenized asset information are in larger management, by way of granting and revoking entry, in addition to information sharing. Tokenization additionally enhances the scopes for information monetization by permitting customers to willingly and securely share their private information with particular events solely.Automated Compliance – Compliance is a significant factor in asset administration. Sensible contracts might show useful in automating this course of. In flip, this might scale back the losses brought on by compliance-related errors.

To dive deeper into this matter, let’s perceive the instance of actual property asset administration utilizing Blockchain-based tokenisation.

Actual Property – The Largest Gainer

Though many industries will profit from tokenization in asset administration, the actual property trade will most likely be the most important gainer.

The trade is big. In India alone, the actual property trade is anticipated to have 3.7 million sq. ft. as inventory in 2019. Furthermore, by 2030, actual property might account for 13% of the Indian GDP, with a market cap of USD 1 trillion.

The issues outlined within the ‘The Current State of Asset Administration’ part are inherent to the worldwide actual property trade, together with India. Furthermore, the illiquidity of actual property property compels a roughly 10-20% hole between the promoting worth and the precise worth of properties. And, liquidity is one thing that tokenization brings to the desk, making the market extra worthwhile for sellers and consumers alike.

In Conclusion

To conclude, tokenization and Blockchain implementation would rule out the various intermediaries concerned within the asset administration course of. This can scale back prices, heighten effectivity, improve transparency, and mitigate rampant corruption. Evidently, asset managers would reap monetary advantages from this transformation as nicely.

Continue Reading


Blockchain for sneakers: New Balance pairs with basketball star for pilot



Shoe producer New Stability has teamed up with LA Clippers star Kawhi Leonard and know-how engineering firm IOHK for a blockchain pilot that includes its new sneaker, launched right now.

Dubbed the OMN1S, the sneaker is New Stability’s first basketball shoe, and the partnership is the primary retail deployment of the Cardano blockchain, developed by Wyoming-based IOHK.

Followers can report possession of their box-fresh OMN1S, accessible in six colorways, on the blockchain, thus guaranteeing authenticity. 

“We’re serving to clients really feel assured that the footwear they’re buying fulfill[s] the standard promise that’s central to the New Stability model,” mentioned Ian Fitzpatrick, Head of International Content material and Digital Advertising and marketing at New Stability, in a press release. 

Welcome to the Enjoyable Home

For 3 days, beginning right now, the sneakers might be accessible at an unique New Stability x Shoe Palace pop-up store, Kawhi’s Enjoyable Home, on LA’s Melrose Avenue. 

Prospects can even obtain a “Realchain” card with an embedded identification and safety chip, with which they will use to say possession by registering a code on footwear on the blockchain through an app

“It is only the start of a long run relationship,” IOHK Chief Govt Charles Hoskinson advised Decrypt on the finish of final month when the pilot was first annnounced.

He additionally spoke of the know-how’s potential for different excessive worth manufacturers, and for secondary market locations corresponding to eBay, the place blockchain authentication “makes an amazing quantity of sense for shopper safety.”

As demand for premium sneakers has grown, a secondary market has bubbled up, and is now believed to be price between $300 million to $1 billion.


Be the primary to get Decrypt Members. A brand new kind of account constructed on blockchain.

Early entry

Nevertheless, this isn’t the primary time blockchain has been used to authenticate sneakers. Chronicled Inc, a classic sneaker firm, raised $3.four million in 2016 for his or her “blockchain verification platform.”

Cardano launched its testnet for the decentralized model of its blockchain final month, and is planning a serious rollout of recent options over the approaching months.

Continue Reading


LUXORR MEDIA GROUP LUXORR MEDIA, the news and media division of LUXORR INC, is an international multimedia and information news provider reaching all seven continents and available in 10 languages. LUXORR MEDIA provides a trusted focus on a new generation of news and information that matters with a world citizen perspective. LUXORR Global Network operates and via LUXORR MEDIA TV.

Translate »